The Internet Juggling Database


endeesjafrcaitherudanlel

Juggling Creativity

Scott Seltzer - 6th June, 2001.

If I see another person in the competitions doing boring runs of 3 club backcrosses, or even worse, Mills Mess, I think I will totally lose respect for a majority of the performers. Granted I do understand that the competitions are being judged 60% for techincal and 40% for performance, I don't think that justifies these tricks that 1. aren't that difficult and 2. don't push the limits of juggling creatively. I find many of these tricks to really show off the lack of individuality of the performer.

For example, many routines are composed mainly of tricks that are taught in "The Complete Juggler." Although a good book with some difficult tricks, I think that the point of the competitions is to showcase something different. I don't want to see a performance that 1. I've virtually seen many times before and 2. I can essentially read in the comfort of my home.

It seems to happen too often that among the small handful of competitors, there are always a few that I can't remember or I confuse because they routines are so generic (especially in the Juniors).

I think that many of the competitors have excellent skills and a nice, safe, commercial act, but that is not what I want to see in the competitions. I want to see people pushing limits. I want to see something I've never seen before. I want tricks that take my breath away and inspire me. I want routines that make me feel something.

Performers should be able to add a little bit of their own ideas to the standards. This on a basic level means putting together nice combinations on the standard tricks. It also means doing some unique variations. But relatively little has been done and the possibilities of the juggling art are endless.

There are some exceptions to juggling standard tricks. A nice display of numbers juggling can be appropriate for some routines. But I totally disagree with the compulsory 5 club and 7 ball flashes or cascades that many people include in their routines. A simple thing that can be done to distinguish oneself is to have a fancy start and/or finish. I also have no problem with certain major tricks like 5 club backcrosses; although it's been seen before it's so technically difficult that it's worthy of inclusion.

A nice creative routine from the 1996 Championships is Scott Sorenson. Although he used a standard prop, he took it to a new level and must be commended.

He set himself apart by juggling only rings, and avoiding balls and clubs. He took a novel approach by not including the usual pulldowns and breakdowns that are often the mainstay of a ring routine. And he didn't avoid 3 rings like most would; as a matter of fact, he did some unusual effects with 3 rings. Topped off with original costuming and unique music for a juggling act, Scott showed us that he really thought things out. (As a further kudos to Scott, he only a year before showed one of the stalest routines I'd seen in the Seniors for a while with mostly unoriginal tricks with clubs and rings. But he showed beautiful growth in skills and presentation in 1996.)

Other worthy examples include Eric Wenoker with a lovely ball routine in 1993 and Jay Gilligan who has original routines every year, particularly his 1996 routine.

Generic tricks not to do in a juggling competition:

  • 5 clubs without tricks.
  • 7 balls without tricks.
  • 3 club (or worse 3 ball) Mills Mess.
  • alberts or treblas unless you can do them solid. Doing them on one side just shows me that you can't really do the trick well.
  • 3 club backcrosses.
  • 3 club shower turning in a circle.
  • standard 5 ring breakdown routine.
  • 3 ball shower alternating directions and then box.

All of these are nice tricks, but as they are I don't think that they are appropriate for the competitions. They can all be varied to make something new and interesting. Jugglers should take risks, especially in the competitions.

Looking beyond the vests and over-used music, I think the biggest problem recently has been lack of creative tricks in the competitions.


post a new message
17th Aug 2006
what is your problem?
Hi, why do you watch pointless competitions anyway, and how do you get the idea that you would see somethink unique there? And who do you think you are to tell people what to do or not to do? Better make a platform for artistic performance, than to condemn other peoples work, enjoyment and believe!
19th Sep 2005
frank, you seem to have missed...
frank, you seem to have missed that I was only referring to IJA juggling competitions. That is where I think creativity is generally lacking. When people juggle elsewhere, I have no problems with whatever they want to do.
10th Sep 2005
Although it's useful to know t...
Although it's useful to know the basic tricks that are almost common knowledge, it really is the essence of a competition that new tricks and ideas are shown off. If, in a competition, you repeat something that someone's already done, and don't go anywhere with it, you are admitting that your juggling skills and creativity are both inferior to whoever started doing that trick by copying them. If you want to be better, you have to make a better trick.
22nd Aug 2005
The article above is negative....
The article above is negative.I am not,neither is my juggling or anybody elses.Juggling is for everybody and if a person wishes to juggle good,bad,or indifferent then that is totally up to them.There is no need to be so negative about why there are so many problems in the juggling conventions.In my opinion there are no problems only happy jugglers.If you have a problem with unimaginative conventions create your own.Now that would be something postive,meanwhile i will continue with my mundane juggling skills while i contain myself within my utter happiness.If you happen to see me doing mills mess i will try not to feel sorry for your unhappiness.all my juggling love to you and remember "happy juggler=happy world=peace"
2nd May 2005
is there a standard time farm ...
is there a standard time farm for how long a routine should be?
6th Aug 2004
What's the deal with 3 club sh...
What's the deal with 3 club shower while running in circles. Isn't it easier than staying in one place. To me it just looks like the juggler can't stay still while he/she juggles.
22nd Feb 2004
Are there video competions out...
Are there video competions out there? Living where I do, I can't make it to any real ones; but I believe that I have created an extremely creative, very out of the box routine that is sure to make people wonder what the heck just happened. Even if there are no vid. competitions I'll post it on the net anyway, I think that you guys will get a kick out of it.
-=[Peace]=-
11th Feb 2004
I agree with most of what is s...
I agree with most of what is said here. If you're going to juggle a predictable trick like 3b mills, at least take the time to show some variations and the like. I freely admit that I'm a fairly crap juggler, but in all my time juggling I've never seen anyone juggle an 8 minute 3 ball routine without repeating a trick. I did this in two parts at the recent Sydney Juggling Convention and received the people's choice award. Not because what I did was all that technically difficult, but more because no one had seen it before, and they found it interesting to see all my variations.
Scott is most definately right, originality is the key to winning a (juggling) audience's heart. Unfortunately (and maybe I'm biased from watching Jason Garfield's videos too many times) but it seems like IJA and other competition organisers don't take this into consideration...
6th Aug 2003
Juggling needs to represent th...
Juggling needs to represent the imagination of its creator. If this doesn't happen all we see is mills mess and backcrosses with three clubs.. The juggling scene in North America sure isn't as powerful as that of Europe and Latin America.. Lets all push ourselves..
13th May 2003
Sean McKinney did a 3 club sho...
Sean McKinney did a 3 club shower in circles,3ball mills mess, and started his routine with more than 20catches of 3club backcrosses and still won 2nd in 1999IJA. Its not the tricks that matter, its the presentation.
1 2 Next